Alternatives to Ignoring an IRS Information Request on Form 1023
If you are thinking about ignoring an IRS information request on your Form 1023 or 1023-EZ, the short answer is: do not. Ignoring the letter costs you the $275 or $600 user fee you already paid, forces a new application with a new fee if you want to try again, and leaves your organization in legal limbo without 501(c)(3) status. Every alternative — including asking for more time — is better than silence. Here are the realistic options, ranked by effort and cost.
What Actually Happens if You Ignore the Letter
When the IRS sends Letter 1312 or a pre-determination document request, you have 28 calendar days from the mailing date to respond. If nothing arrives by the deadline, the EO Specialist follows Failure to Establish (FTE) procedures:
- Your case is closed administratively. This is not a legal determination that your organization does not qualify — it is a procedural closure because the IRS did not receive the information it needed to make a decision.
- Your user fee is generally not refunded. The $600 (Form 1023) or $275 (Form 1023-EZ) you paid when you filed is gone.
- To try again, you file a new application. If the group manager does not reopen the case for a valid reason, you must submit a new Pay.gov application with a new user fee.
- You do not yet have an IRS determination. Until the IRS issues a determination letter, your organization is not recognized as tax-exempt. Contributors do not have advance assurance of deductibility while your application is pending; if the organization ultimately qualifies for the period when a contribution was made, the contribution is deductible. Institutional grantmakers will not disburse funds. Banks may restrict your account. Fiscal sponsors may prepare to offboard your project.
FTE closure letters arrive as Letter 1314 (Form 1023) or Letter 1049 (Form 1023-EZ). Once closed, reopening requires either demonstrating a valid reason for the late response (at the group manager's discretion) or filing a new application.
The Four Alternatives
1. Request an Extension (Free, Takes 10 Minutes)
If you cannot put together a full response within 28 days, call the EO Specialist listed on your letter and request an extension before the deadline passes. The specialist can grant up to 14 additional days based on the facts and circumstances. If you need more time than that, the specialist's group manager can approve a longer extension.
This is the minimum viable action. Even if you are overwhelmed by the questions, unsure how to answer them, or waiting to hear back from a pro bono clinic, requesting an extension keeps your case open and your user fee protected. The worst outcome of calling is that the specialist says no — in which case you are exactly where you would have been anyway, with the original deadline intact.
2. Respond Yourself Using Free IRS Resources (Free, 15–25 Hours of Work)
The IRS publishes everything you need to construct a response: Publication 557 explains exemption law, the Internal Revenue Manual (IRM 7.20) describes how specialists evaluate applications, and Stay Exempt (IRS.gov) offers education on applying for exemption and ongoing compliance. The challenge is that these resources are organized by regulatory topic, not by "how to answer the five questions in this letter."
This approach works if your board includes someone willing to spend 15–25 hours reading regulatory material, drafting answers, and assembling a response package. The risk is that a self-assembled response misses the structure the IRS expects — numbered answers matching the letter's questions, indexed supporting documents, and the perjury declaration signed by an authorized officer — which can trigger a second round of questions.
3. Use a Self-Help Response Guide (10–20 Hours of Work)
A guide designed specifically for the IRS information request stage bridges the gap between free resources and professional help. The IRS Information Request Response Guide provides worksheets for each step: decoding the letter, calculating the deadline, structuring your activity narrative around the information Form 1023 requests, reconciling financial data, handling organizational document amendments, and assembling the response package for submission.
This is the option that fits most volunteer boards: immediate access and a structured workflow. You still do the work — the guide tells you what the IRS wants, in what order, and how to format it, but your board gathers the evidence and writes the answers.
4. Hire a Nonprofit Attorney ($1,500–$5,000+, Delegation)
An attorney takes the drafting burden off your board and can communicate directly with the EO Specialist using Form 2848 Power of Attorney. This is the right choice when the IRS is raising issues beyond routine documentation — private foundation classification, political activity concerns, significant related-party transactions, or anything that feels like it is heading toward a proposed adverse determination rather than a request for clarification.
The practical constraint is time and money. Attorney intake and scheduling can take one to three weeks, which may consume half your 28-day window. And $1,500–$5,000 in legal fees is a significant amount for an organization that may not yet have its first year of revenue.
Decision Framework
| Your situation | Best alternative |
|---|---|
| Overwhelmed and do not know where to start | Request an extension, then start with option 2 or 3 |
| Tight deadline but routine questions (activity narrative, financial data, document amendments) | Self-help response guide (option 3) |
| Complex questions about private benefit, political activity, or foundation classification | Hire an attorney (option 4) |
| Zero budget, comfortable reading regulatory material | Free IRS resources (option 2) |
| Already past the deadline | Call the specialist's group manager to discuss reopening; if that fails, prepare a new application |
Free Download
Get the IRS Information Request Response Checklist
Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.
Who Ends Up Ignoring the Letter (and Why)
The boards that ignore IRS information requests are rarely making a deliberate decision. The pattern is simpler: the volunteer who monitors the organization's mail does not understand what the letter is asking, assumes it is bad news, sets it aside to deal with later, and later never comes. By the time someone else on the board asks about the application status, the 28-day window has closed.
The fix is awareness: when the letter arrives, the first action is calculating the deadline, not reading the questions. Once the board knows when time runs out, the urgency of choosing an approach becomes concrete.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the IRS reopen a case after FTE closure?
The group manager decides whether a closed case will be reopened when the organization presents a valid reason for the late response. If the case is not reopened, the organization must file a new application through Pay.gov with the applicable user fee.
Is requesting an extension seen negatively by the IRS?
No. Requesting an extension is a normal part of the process. The IRS manual explicitly provides for extensions of up to 14 days at the specialist's discretion, and longer extensions with manager approval. It signals that you are engaged with the process and working toward a complete response.
What if I can only answer some of the questions by the deadline?
Submit what you have. A partial response that addresses the questions you can answer, with a clear note identifying which items you are still working on, is vastly better than no response at all. The specialist may grant additional time for the remaining items or issue a second development letter. Neither outcome closes your case.
Does FTE closure mean the IRS decided we do not qualify?
No. Failure to Establish is an administrative closure, not a legal determination on the merits. It means the IRS did not receive enough information to make a decision. The distinction matters because an adverse determination triggers appeal rights; an FTE closure generally does not, though you can ask for the case to be reopened.
How many organizations lose their applications to FTE closure each year?
The IRS does not publish annual FTE closure statistics as a standalone figure. The IRS Exempt Organizations function reports processing statistics in its annual Data Book, but FTE closures are not broken out separately from other case dispositions. What is known: volunteer-run organizations are disproportionately affected because they lack dedicated administrative staff to monitor and respond to regulatory correspondence.
Get Your Free IRS Information Request Response Checklist
Download the IRS Information Request Response Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.