$0 IRS Information Request Response Checklist

Form 1023 Rejection Reasons

A letter from the IRS saying your 501(c)(3) application was denied or closed is not the news anyone wants after spending $600 on the Form 1023 user fee and months waiting for a decision. Understanding why the IRS rejected the application is the first step toward figuring out what comes next — whether that means fixing the problem and reapplying, filing an appeal, or reconsidering whether the organization qualifies at all.

There are three distinct ways an application can end without approval, and they carry different consequences.

Closed for Failure to Establish (FTE)

The most common reason an application ends unsuccessfully is not a substantive denial — it is an administrative closure because the applicant did not respond to an IRS information request within the deadline.

When an EO Specialist sends a development letter (typically Letter 1312) asking for additional information, the organization has 28 calendar days from the letter's mailing date to respond. If nothing arrives, the IRS closes the case as a Failure to Establish and sends Letter 1314 (for Form 1023) or Letter 1049 (for Form 1023-EZ).

An FTE closure is not a ruling that your organization does not qualify. It simply means the IRS did not have enough information to make a decision. The user fee is not refunded, and you generally need to file a new application with a new fee to restart the process. If you believe the closure was an IRS error (the letter went to the wrong address, for example), contact the manager identified in the correspondence to discuss next steps.

Proposed Adverse Determination

A proposed adverse determination is the IRS telling you, based on the record so far, that your organization does not meet the requirements for 501(c)(3) status. This is a preliminary finding, not a final one.

The most common substantive reasons behind a proposed adverse determination:

Failing the organizational test. Your articles of incorporation are missing a required purpose clause limiting activities to exempt purposes, or a dissolution clause dedicating assets to another 501(c)(3) or government entity upon dissolution. Treasury Regulation § 1.501(c)(3)-1(b) requires both.

Failing the operational test. The IRS concluded that the organization's actual or planned activities do not primarily further exempt purposes. This can happen when the activity description is too vague ("educating the public," "promoting wellness"), when planned activities primarily benefit private individuals rather than a charitable class, or when the organization looks like a commercial enterprise.

Private inurement or excessive private benefit. Compensation to founders, officers, or insiders that exceeds fair market value, or leases, contracts, and transactions between the organization and insiders on terms that do not reflect arm's-length dealings.

Political campaign intervention. Any participation in political campaigns for or against candidates — even indirect activity like voter guides with a clear partisan tilt — disqualifies an organization under IRC § 501(c)(3).

Excessive lobbying. While 501(c)(3) organizations may do some lobbying, it cannot be a substantial part of their activities unless they made the § 501(h) election and stay within the expenditure limits.

When you receive a proposed adverse determination, you have 30 calendar days to file a written protest requesting review by the IRS Independent Office of Appeals. The protest must explain why you disagree with each point in the proposed adverse letter and include any supporting documentation.

Final Adverse Determination

If you do not file a protest within 30 days, or if the Independent Office of Appeals upholds the denial, the IRS issues a Final Adverse Determination Letter. This is the definitive administrative denial.

After a final adverse determination, you have 90 calendar days to file a declaratory judgment action under IRC § 7428 in one of three courts: the U.S. Tax Court, the Court of Federal Claims, or the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia. This is a judicial proceeding and typically requires legal representation.

Free Download

Get the IRS Information Request Response Checklist

Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.

Form 1023-EZ Specific Rejections

Form 1023-EZ applications face an additional rejection path: the IRS selects a percentage of 1023-EZ submissions for pre-determination review. If that review reveals the organization was ineligible for the streamlined form — gross receipts above $50,000 in any of the past three tax years or projected above $50,000 in any of the next three years, total assets above $250,000, or a “Yes” answer on the Eligibility Worksheet — the application is rejected.

This rejection is not a denial of exempt status. The organization needs to submit a full Form 1023 through Pay.gov with the $600 user fee.

What to Do After a Rejection

The path forward depends on which kind of rejection you received:

  • FTE closure: File a new application and fee. This time, respond promptly to any information request within the 28-day window. If you need more time, call the specialist before the deadline to request an extension.
  • Proposed adverse determination: File a written protest within 30 days. Address every issue raised in the letter with specific documentation.
  • Final adverse determination: Consult an attorney about whether a declaratory judgment action is viable.
  • 1023-EZ eligibility rejection: Submit the full Form 1023 instead.

If your organization received a development letter and you want to avoid the most common rejection path — missing the deadline or submitting an incomplete response — the IRS Information Request Guide covers the entire response process from reading the letter through confirming delivery.

Related reading: IRS Application Closed as Incomplete — How to Reapply · IRS Response Deadline and Extensions · Form 1023 vs Form 1023-EZ

Get Your Free IRS Information Request Response Checklist

Download the IRS Information Request Response Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.

Learn More →