IRS Questions About Your Scholarship Program on Form 1023
Scholarship programs draw extra scrutiny on Form 1023 because the IRS needs to confirm that grants go to a charitable class — not to handpicked individuals who happen to know the founders. If your development letter asks about your scholarship program, the specialist is evaluating whether your selection process, oversight, and record-keeping meet the requirements for grants to individuals under Section 501(c)(3).
What the IRS Is Evaluating
The IRS asks all organizations that provide educational grants to individuals to complete Schedule H and explain how the grants further their exempt purposes. Section 4945's advance-approval rules apply to private foundations, not public charities generally. The specialist is looking at three things:
1. Objective selection criteria. How do you decide who gets a scholarship? The IRS says educational distributions generally further exempt purposes when selection is nondiscriminatory, based on need and/or merit, and available to an open-ended charitable class rather than preselected individuals. "The board picks deserving students" isn't objective enough.
2. No private benefit to insiders. Scholarships can't be a device to confer private benefit on handpicked insiders. Private foundation company scholarship programs may give preference to employees' children or relatives when they meet the IRS's additional requirements. If the pool of eligible applicants is so narrow that the same few people always benefit, the IRS will question whether this is really a charitable program or a private benefit arrangement.
3. Supervision and reporting. Schedule H asks how educational grants further your exempt purposes. A scholarship is tax-free to a recipient only when the recipient meets the applicable requirements and uses it for qualified education expenses. Private foundations seeking advance approval under Section 4945 must describe their grant procedures; explain the safeguards and reporting practices that apply to your program.
How to Respond to Scholarship Questions
Your response should address each of the specialist's questions and include:
A written scholarship policy. If you don't have one yet, draft it before responding. The policy should state:
- Eligibility criteria (who can apply)
- Selection criteria (how winners are chosen)
- The selection committee composition (independent of recipients and their families)
- Award amounts and what expenses they cover
- Requirements for recipients (enrollment verification, grade reports, expense documentation)
The selection process in detail. Describe how applications are solicited, who reviews them, how the committee scores or ranks applicants, and how final decisions are made. If you use a scoring rubric, attach it.
Nondiscrimination safeguards. Explain how you ensure the selection process doesn't favor insiders. An independent selection committee — people who have no family or business relationship with applicants — is the clearest safeguard.
Supervision procedures. How do you verify that recipients use funds for educational purposes? Common approaches include requiring recipients to submit enrollment verification and tuition receipts, and paying institutions directly rather than giving cash to students.
Common Problems That Trigger Follow-Up
Selection criteria are too vague. "Deserving students in our community" doesn't tell the specialist how you distinguish between applicants. State the specific factors and their relative weight.
The selection committee includes insiders. For private foundation company scholarship programs, the selection committee must be independent of the foundation, organizer, and employer. In other programs, manage conflicts so selectors cannot influence awards to themselves or relatives.
No monitoring after the award. A scholarship program that sends money and never follows up on how it was spent raises private benefit concerns. Describe your verification procedures.
Scholarships limited to a single employer's workforce. Employer-related programs have additional IRS requirements. Private foundations must obtain advance approval under Section 4945(g) for individual grant procedures; Section 117(c) treats an amount as taxable when it pays a student for services required as a condition of the scholarship.
Free Download
Get the IRS Information Request Response Checklist
Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.
What to Attach
Include these as exhibits with your response:
- Written scholarship program policy
- Selection criteria or scoring rubric
- Sample application form
- List of selection committee members (with a note confirming independence from applicants)
- Description of monitoring and reporting procedures
For the full framework on structuring scholarship program responses and other common development letter topics, the IRS Information Request Response Guide includes a question-to-evidence matrix and assembly checklist.
Get Your Free IRS Information Request Response Checklist
Download the IRS Information Request Response Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.