PA Charity Registration Deficiency Letter: What It Means and How to Fix It
What a Deficiency Notice Means
When the Bureau of Corporations and Charitable Organizations reviews your Form BCO-10 and finds it incomplete or inconsistent, they issue a Notice of Deficiency. This is not a rejection — it means your filing is on hold until you provide the missing information or correct the errors.
The deficient statement itself is not approval. You may solicit only while an existing registration is current or an exemption applies. If a required renewal is past due, late fees continue to accrue.
The Most Common Deficiency Triggers
The same errors show up repeatedly:
Missing second signature. BCO-10 requires signatures from two different authorized officers, one of whom must be the chief fiscal officer or equivalent. A single signature does not meet that requirement.
Omitting Form BCO-23. If you file IRS Form 990-N, 990-EZ, 990-PF, or are part of a group return, Form BCO-23 (Public Disclosure Statement) must accompany your BCO-10. Many small organizations file a 990-N e-Postcard and assume no supplemental form is needed.
Using state-only contribution figures. The Bureau calculates your fee tier and financial reporting requirements based on gross annual national contributions — the total from all sources nationwide. Reporting only Pennsylvania contributions puts you in the wrong tier and triggers a correction.
Submitting the wrong level of financial statement. For a standard registration, if contributions exceed $100,000, internally prepared statements are not sufficient. The Bureau needs at least a CPA compilation ($100,000–$249,999), a CPA review ($250,000–$749,999), or a full audit ($750,000+). Organizations using a short-form registration under 10 P.S. § 162.7(a) do not file a financial report.
These tiers apply to contributions received through calendar year 2027. Act 104 of 2026 changes the tiers for contributions received in calendar years beginning January 1, 2028: a CPA compilation, review, or audit is optional below $150,000; a compilation, review, or audit is required from $150,000 to less than $500,000; a review or audit from $500,000 to less than $1,000,000; and an audit at $1,000,000 or more.
Incomplete IRS Form 990. Attaching only the front pages without the public schedules is a deficiency. Include the complete, signed return (excluding Schedule B donor lists unless you file 990-PF).
How to Respond to a Deficiency Notice
The notice will identify what is missing or incorrect. Your response should be targeted:
- Gather the specific documents or corrections requested. Do not resubmit the entire package unless asked — provide only the missing pieces.
- Reference your registration number in all correspondence so the Bureau can match your response to the pending filing.
- Submit through the online portal if you filed electronically, or by mail if you filed on paper. Keep portal confirmations or certified mailing receipts as proof of response.
- Respond promptly. The Act allows 15 days after you receive notice that the requirements are not satisfied to request a hearing. Follow any separate response deadline in the notice. If this is a required renewal filed late, the $25/month late fee continues to accrue.
Free Download
Get the Pennsylvania Charity Registration Checklist
Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.
Preventing Deficiency Notices
The fix is preparation, not luck. Before submitting your BCO-10:
- Confirm you have both required signatures
- Check whether your IRS return type triggers the BCO-23 requirement
- Verify your contribution figures match what your Form 990 reports
- Confirm your financial statements meet the tier for your contribution level
- Update the professional fundraiser details requested by BCO-10; file any required contracts separately with the Bureau
- Include the correct registration fee for your contribution tier
The Pennsylvania BCO Charity Registration guide includes a pre-submission checklist designed to catch every common deficiency trigger before you file.
Get Your Free Pennsylvania Charity Registration Checklist
Download the Pennsylvania Charity Registration Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.