$0 New York Charity Registration Checklist

New York Department of State Annual Report for Charities: The 172-b(9) Filing Most Nonprofits Miss

You filed your CHAR500 with the Attorney General's Charities Bureau, submitted your IRS Form 990, and assumed you were done for the year. Then you learned about Executive Law Section 172-b(9) — a separate annual financial report that certain organizations must also file with the New York Department of State, with a $25 fee and its own filing instructions. Most small charities do not know this obligation exists until they receive a notice.

What Is the 172-b(9) Filing?

Executive Law Section 172-b(9) requires a registered charitable organization that must file a funding disclosure report under Section 172-e and/or a financial disclosure report under Section 172-f during the fiscal year to also file its annual financial report with the New York Department of State. This is a parallel obligation — it exists alongside the CHAR500 filing with the Attorney General, not as a replacement for it.

The filing includes a copy of the organization's annual financial report and a $25 fee payable to the Department of State.

This requirement applies to organizations that must file a funding disclosure report under Section 172-e and/or a financial disclosure report under Section 172-f for a reporting period during the applicable fiscal year.

Who Must File

Not every registered charity owes this filing. The obligation is tied to Article 7-A registration (meaning you solicit contributions in New York) combined with the funding or financial disclosure triggers in Sections 172-e and 172-f.

If your organization is registered only under EPTL Section 8-1.4 (you hold charitable assets in New York but do not actively solicit contributions), this particular Department of State filing does not apply to you.

The practical test: if you file a CHAR500 with the Attorney General under Article 7-A or DUAL registration status, check whether your financial activity also triggers the 172-b(9) reporting obligation to the Department of State.

Deadline

The annual financial report to the Department of State is due by the 15th day of the 5th calendar month following the end of your organization's fiscal year. For a calendar-year organization, that is May 15.

For organizations subject to this requirement, the Department of State report shares the CHAR500 filing deadline for Article 7-A and DUAL registrants. The two reports go to different agencies: the CHAR500 goes to the Attorney General's Charities Bureau, and the 172-b(9) report goes to the Department of State.

Free Download

Get the New York Charity Registration Checklist

Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.

How to File

The 172-b(9) filing is submitted online through the Department of State's Financial Reporting System, not through the Attorney General's online portal at portalcharities.ag.ny.gov. Filers need a NY.Gov account.

Include:

  • Your annual financial report for the completed fiscal year
  • A $25 filing fee

The Department of State's website says all reports are filed online. The Attorney General's Charities Bureau portal does not handle this filing for you.

Why This Gets Missed

Three reasons this obligation catches organizations by surprise:

It is a separate agency. Charities in New York interact with at least three agencies — the Department of State (incorporation and 172-b(9) reports), the Attorney General (CHAR410 registration and CHAR500 annual filings), and the IRS (Form 990). The 172-b(9) filing sits with the Department of State, an agency that most charities associate only with their initial Certificate of Incorporation.

The CHAR500 feels comprehensive. The CHAR500 annual filing to the Attorney General is detailed — it includes financial statements, fee calculations, and registration status updates. Filers reasonably assume it covers all state reporting. It does not.

Guidance is fragmented. The Attorney General's published instructions for the CHAR500 focus on Charities Bureau requirements. The Department of State's own guidance addresses corporate filings. The 172-b(9) obligation sits at the intersection and is easy to overlook in either agency's materials.

How to Build This Into Your Calendar

If your organization files under Article 7-A or DUAL status and must also file under Section 172-e or 172-f, add the 172-b(9) report to the same calendar reminder. Both annual financial reports are due on the 15th day of the 5th calendar month after fiscal year-end. Preparing them at the same time — using the same financial statements — keeps the administrative burden low.

The New York Charities Bureau Registration Guide includes an annual compliance calendar that tracks the CHAR500, the 172-b(9) report, and the IRS Form 990 together, so you can see all three deadlines in one place.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the 172-b(9) filing the same as the CHAR500?

No. The CHAR500 is filed with the Attorney General's Charities Bureau. The 172-b(9) annual financial report is filed separately with the Department of State when the organization meets the statutory reporting trigger. The annual financial reports share the 15th-day-of-the-fifth-month deadline, but go to different agencies and serve different statutory purposes.

What happens if I miss the 172-b(9) filing?

Failing to file can result in penalties or compliance issues with the Department of State. The specific consequences depend on your organization's registration status and the length of the delinquency. If you have missed prior years, file them as soon as possible.

Does a charity registered only under EPTL need to file with the Department of State?

The 172-b(9) obligation applies to organizations registered or required to be registered under Article 7-A that also meet the funding or financial disclosure triggers. EPTL-only registrants are generally not subject to this particular filing, though they still owe the CHAR500 to the Attorney General.

Can I file the 172-b(9) report through the Attorney General's online portal?

No. The 172-b(9) report goes to the Department of State, which has its own submission process. The Attorney General's portal at portalcharities.ag.ny.gov handles CHAR410 and CHAR500 filings only.

Get Your Free New York Charity Registration Checklist

Download the New York Charity Registration Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.

Learn More →