New York Executive Law 172-b: Charity CPA Audit and Review Thresholds
What Executive Law § 172-b Requires
New York Executive Law § 172-b sets mandatory financial reporting standards for charities registered or required to be registered under Article 7-A. The rule is straightforward: the larger your organization's revenue, the more rigorous the financial report you must attach to your annual Form CHAR500.
The thresholds reached their final statutory levels on July 1, 2021, and they apply to every Article 7-A and DUAL registrant.
The Three Tiers
| Total Gross Revenue and Support | Required Financial Report |
|---|---|
| Under $250,000 | Unaudited financial statements prepared internally |
| $250,001 to $1,000,000 | Independent CPA review report |
| Over $1,000,000 | Independent CPA audit report |
The CPA review must be performed by an independent certified public accountant under the AICPA's Statements on Standards for Accounting and Review Services. The audited financial statements must be prepared in conformity with GAAP (Generally Accepted Accounting Principles).
How "Total Gross Revenue and Support" Is Measured
This is not just donations. Total gross revenue and support includes every revenue stream your organization reports:
- Public contributions and foundation grants
- Government funding
- Program service revenue (fees, tuition, ticket sales)
- Membership dues
- Special event proceeds
- Investment income
The figure corresponds to Line 12 of IRS Form 990 or Line 9 of Form 990-EZ. This is the number you use when determining which tier applies to your organization.
Free Download
Get the New York Charity Registration Checklist
Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.
Why This Matters for Small Charities
Most volunteer-run charities with annual revenue under $250,000 can prepare their own financial statements without hiring a CPA. This keeps compliance costs low.
The pressure point comes when your organization approaches the $250,000 threshold. Crossing it means you need an independent CPA to prepare a review report — and CPA reviews cost money, typically several thousand dollars depending on your organization's complexity. Treasurers who do not track this threshold can find themselves scrambling to hire a CPA after the fiscal year has already closed, with the CHAR500 deadline looming.
For organizations approaching $1 million in revenue, the jump from a CPA review to a full CPA audit is even more significant. Audit fees for nonprofits at this level can run from $5,000 to $15,000 or more.
Planning Ahead
The practical takeaway for board treasurers: know your numbers before the fiscal year ends. If your organization's revenue is trending toward $250,000 or $1 million, start the CPA engagement early. Finding a qualified accountant willing to take on a nonprofit review or audit takes time, and rushing the process after your fiscal year closes creates unnecessary stress.
Also track the direction of travel. A charity that received a one-time $200,000 grant might report $280,000 in total revenue for a single year, triggering the CPA review tier. If that grant is not recurring, the following year's revenue may drop back below the threshold. The rule applies year by year — you assess each fiscal period independently.
EPTL-Only Registrants
The § 172-b audit thresholds apply specifically to organizations registered under Article 7-A or DUAL. EPTL-only registrants are not subject to these CPA requirements, though they still must submit financial statements with their annual CHAR500 filing.
The New York Charities Bureau Registration Guide includes an Executive Law § 172-b Audit Threshold Calculator worksheet that maps your revenue to the correct reporting tier and helps your board budget for CPA costs before they become a deadline emergency.
Get Your Free New York Charity Registration Checklist
Download the New York Charity Registration Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.