New York Executive Law Article 7-A vs EPTL 8-1.4: Which Statute Applies to Your Charity
Why New York Has Two Charity Registration Statutes
Most states regulate charities under a single charitable solicitation law. New York uses two, and they serve different purposes. Understanding which one applies — or whether both do — determines your registration category, your fees, and your annual reporting obligations.
Executive Law Article 7-A regulates the act of soliciting charitable contributions. If your organization asks people in New York or a governmental agency for donations — through mail, email, events, a website donation page, or grant applications — Article 7-A generally applies, subject to statutory exemptions. The focus is on donor protection and fundraising transparency.
EPTL § 8-1.4 (Estates, Powers and Trusts Law) regulates the holding and administration of charitable property. If your organization holds, receives, or administers property allocated to charitable purposes in New York, EPTL generally applies — even if you never solicit a single donation; statutory exemptions apply. The focus is on fiduciary stewardship of charitable assets.
The Four Registration Categories
When you file Form CHAR410 through the Charities Bureau online portal, you must select one of four categories:
| Category | Trigger | Initial Fee |
|---|---|---|
| 7A | Solicits contributions in New York | $25 |
| EPTL | Holds charitable assets in New York but does not solicit | $0 |
| DUAL | Both solicits and holds assets | $25 |
| Exempt | Meets statutory exemption criteria under one or both statutes | $0 |
Most small charities that both fundraise and hold a bank account or other property for charitable purposes fall into the DUAL category.
How the Statutes Affect Annual Fees
The distinction matters most at annual filing time. When you submit Form CHAR500 each year, your fees break down by statute:
- Article 7-A fee: $25 for a 7A or DUAL registrant that owes a filing fee; an annual-report exemption claim can reduce it to $0.
- EPTL fee: a sliding scale based on your organization's net worth — from $25 (under $50,000 net worth) up to $1,500 (net worth of $50 million or more).
DUAL registrants pay both fees. If your charity has a net worth under $50,000, the total annual filing fee is $50 ($25 Article 7-A + $25 EPTL).
Free Download
Get the New York Charity Registration Checklist
Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.
How the Statutes Affect Deadlines
Filing deadlines also differ:
- Article 7-A and DUAL filers: Form CHAR500 is due 4.5 months after your fiscal year ends. For a December 31 fiscal year, that is May 15.
- EPTL-only filers: Due 6 months after the fiscal year ends — June 30 for a calendar-year organization.
The Bureau does not accept the federal 990-N e-Postcard. Even if your organization files a 990-N with the IRS, New York requires a full Form 990-EZ to accompany CHAR500.
Common Confusion: Article 7-A Exempt but EPTL Required
A charity raising $15,000 a year without a professional fundraiser or fundraising counsel (exempt from Article 7-A because contributions are under $25,000) that holds a $100,000 investment account is still required to register and file annually under EPTL. The solicitation exemption does not excuse the asset-holding obligation.
This catches organizations that start small and grow their endowment or receive a large bequest. Even if you never cross the $25,000 fundraising threshold, your EPTL duties track your asset holdings independently.
Practical Implications for Volunteer Boards
For a newly formed charity planning to solicit donations and hold a bank account, the right category is almost always DUAL. Register under DUAL from the start, pay the $25 initial fee, and you are covered under both statutes. Trying to register under only one statute to save a few dollars creates compliance risk when your circumstances change.
The New York Charities Bureau Registration Guide includes a Registration Category Decision Worksheet that maps your organization's activities to the correct statutory category and walks through the fee and deadline implications for each.
Get Your Free New York Charity Registration Checklist
Download the New York Charity Registration Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.